Skip to main content

Feeling Must be the Clue to Wholeness

Published on P2P-Foundation here.
Here is another example of the way feeling must be the clue to wholeness, when we seek to make something alive. I once had an interesting discussion with Sim Can der Ryn. He was arguing that feeling is not enough. In his view it was too vague, too emotional. For instance, he said: “In making a sustainable fishpond which works, you just have to concentrate on the facts about fish life, water, plants, and so on, ecological facts about a healthy pond.“

I told him: “It is true that these ecological facts are a necessary part of our knowledge, our understanding of how to make a pond. And it is true that many of us know too little about what it requires to make the world sustainable, harmonious in its biological and chemical detail, and so on. But suppose, indeed, that we are trying to build a fishpond. The facts about the ecology of the pond – no matter how detailed by themselves – will not tell us how to make that pond good. Even if we have theories and facts about sustainability, edge plants, fish, breeding, water temperature, types of weed, types of insect, and so on – even with all of this we will not succeed in making the pond have life unless we also have a clear inner feeling – a subliminal perception, and awareness,and anticipation – of what life in that pond will be like.” That means we must have a dim awareness within us, of what a pond with life is like, as a whole and in its feeling.
Småsalamanderdammen ved Eiktunet friluftsmuseum på Gjøvik.

-Wikimedia.
If we do have that feeling of life clear (for the fishpond), we can then use it to guide us. It will help us move towards a pond which does have life. But if we do not have such a feeling clear in us, no amount of knowledge about ecology and sustainability will get us to a pond that has life in the sense I am discussing.

We shall just be left scrambling mentally, churning about, marshaling our facts, making experiments perhaps – but still not clarified by an inner vision which tells us what to do. Building the pond, stocking it, putting weeds in it, placing bushes around it, we need to be guided by an inner vision of good life in this pond. We must have a feeling, in us, which will reliably tell us when we are going in the right direction, and when we are going in the wrong direction.

It is ultimately this inner feeling, this inner vision of feeling, which is our reliable (and necessary) guide. In short, we must be able to imagine the pond – not as a copy of another pond, or with detailed factual vision about dimension, depth, plants. We must be able to summon up, inside us, an inner sensation of the feeling of a healthy pond, which makes us remember or create the kind of feeling which a good fishpond has: the slow movement of the fish, the edge, the light on the water, the kind of things that may be present at the edge – all this, not in biological or architectural detail – but as a morphological feeling which allows me, in my inner eye, with my eyes closed, to remember, breathe, the kind of soft and subtle feeling of life which such a fishpond requires. It is that vision of feeling which, above all, must guide me. - The Process of Creating Life, by Christopher Alexander, page 375-376

Anti-Feeling

Everyone has common sense. Intelligent people, however, have a tendency to overapply their analytical and logical reasoning abilities derived from their general intelligence incorrectly to such evolutionarily familiar domains and as a result get things wrong. In other words, liberals and other intelligent people lack common sense, because their general intelligence overrides it. They think in situations where they are supposed to feel. In evolutionarily familiar domains such as interpersonal relationships, feeling usually leads to correct solutions whereas thinking does not. - Satoshi Kanazawa

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kapping av hulkillist

Hadde nesten ferdig et hjørne med hulkillister i dag, men så fikk jeg somlet meg til å kappe 2 mm for mye. Da var dagen over og rett hjem og helga ødelagt! Men får tro jeg får en ny dag i mårå? Har funnet litt på nett, så går på med fornyet optimisme over helga. Får trøste meg med at skal man bli god i noe må man minst holde på 10.000 timer.




En god artikkel:
5 snarveier når du skal legge lister
En kommentar: Kort sagt må man tenke motsatt når man lister med hulkil. Se for deg at du legger lista feil vei (den som peker mot/tar i taket) legger du jevnt med underlaget på sagen. Den delen som skal på veggen legger du på anlegget/landet på sagen.  Skjær den første vinkelen du trenger. Så maler du deg ut ifra den, setter merke på den delen som ligger på anlegget/landet på sagen, vrir saga til den vinkelen du skal ha... skjærer forsiktig litt og litt av til du treffer streken...

Så bare til å montere :)

Lite tips er å kappe hulkil lister 1-2 mm for kort, slik at du har litt plass å bevege lis…

Hårdåg i engen VII

Please share coupon code 25in2019 or link below to give the gift of 25% off Flickr Pro now.

https://www.flickr.com/account/upgrade/pro?coupon=25in2019

Har du ikke rukket å kjøpe alle julegavene enda, kjøp et Flickr-medlemsskap til noen du er glad i, denne bildedelings-tjenesten er langt bedre enn Instagram. Den var gratis inntil i fjor, og den har nå blitt enda bedre, men de sliter økonomisk. Flickr er en viktig del av PermaLivs arbeidsflyt, sammen med Wikimedia, så støtter du Flickr støtter du også PermaLivs arbeide!

- Flickr Needs More Pro Members to Stay Afloat

Videre har Trond Andresen en hyggelig hilsen i dag, hvor han igjen tar et oppgjør med de progressive, som har tatt kontroll over media for å forherlige egen klasse og støte oss deplorable ned i helvetet, et sted uten tilhørighet, slik det har blitt her i enga vår!

Om rasisme og antirasisme
Av Trond Andresen
"Antirasisme" kan bare bli troverdig når man slutter med den nedlatende og sjølgode moraliseringa, og anerkjenn…

Hårdåg i engen I

Følg "Hårdåg i engen II"!







Det kommer en tid da historien skal skrives. Våre etterkommere er interessert. - John-Arvid Volden, Utflyttet frøyværing
Selv fotograferer og deler jeg først og fremst for våre etterkommere, slik at de kan ha en historie å skrive, hvis de er interessert. Volden tror de vil være det. I likhet med Volden vil vi snart også være utflyttet, da skjebnen ville det slik at vi skulle være her en tid. Men kommer en vakker sommerkveld, som i går kveld, har man straks denne forskrekkelige gaulingen og kaklingen utover de grønne enger langt inn i sommernatta. Ikke alle forstår at himmelengene er like hellige som en hvilken som helst katedral, dessverre. For her ble husmannstroen født!